Chapter 1
For the seven years we've been mates, my Alpha, Ryan Grayback, has never allowed our pup, Sofia Grayback, to call him "Daddy". He insists that she call him "Alpha Ryan" instead.
But on the day his first love, Claire Barker, returns to the pack, Ryan changes.
That night, the usually aloof Ryan gets drunk for the first time. He smiles as he gathers Sofia into his arms so gently and tenderly, acting for the first time like he's her father.
Sofia is surprised and delighted. She wraps her arms around his neck and whispers to me, "Mommy, is Alpha Ryan starting to like me?"
My eyes redden with tears as I crouch down and pull her into an embrace.
"It's because the person he likes has come back. That's why we shouldn't disturb him anymore."
I decide to take Sofia and leave the pack, but she tugs on my hand and asks, "Mommy, can we please give Alpha Ryan three more chances?"
The first time, Ryan forgets about Sofia's parent night because of Claire.
The second time, Ryan tenderly picks up Claire's pup, Lily Barker, right in front of Sofia.
The third time, he chooses them again without a moment's hesitation.
This time, Sofia gives up on waiting for him. She hugs me tightly and says, "Let's go, Mommy."
So I drink the potion that severs the mate bond and take Sofia away from the pack where we'd lived for seven years. And this time, we are never looking back.
Chapter 1
Erina's POV
After tucking my pup, Sofia Grayback, into bed, I returned to my room. I opened my laptop and began drafting my application to leave the Moonshadow pack.
This year marked the seventh anniversary of my bond with Alpha Ryan Grayback, and it was also the year that I finally decided to let go of him.
A light knock sounded at the door. I looked up and saw my six-year-old Sofia standing there with a tiny rabbit plush in her arms.
"Mommy, are we really going to leave the pack?" She looked up at me, her eyes filled with reluctance. "But Daddy—I mean, the Alpha hugged me tonight."
She gently caressed the rabbit toy in her arm. It was the only toy that Ryan had ever given to her.
She asked cautiously and hopefully, "Do you think that this means the Alpha is starting to like me?"
I froze for a moment, dazed.
In the seven years that I'd been Ryan's mate, he had never allowed our pup to call him "Daddy". He only allowed her to call him "Alpha Ryan".
Once, when Sofia was two years old, Ryan was in a good mood and brought her to a pack gathering for the first time.
When Sofia saw a street vendor selling cotton candy by the roadside, she ran into his arms and exclaimed excitedly in her childish voice, "Daddy! Daddy, can I have cotton candy please?"
Ryan's acquaintances, who were nearby then, all turned to look when they heard her. Ryan's face immediately turned as dark as thunder—all because Sofia had innocently called him "Daddy".
He immediately let go of her, set her on the ground, and made her follow him all the way home by herself—even though she'd only recently learned to run.
"I said, you can only call me 'Alpha'."
That day, Sofia kept crying as she ran home after him, trying to keep up with his footsteps. She fell over many times and had gravel cut her feet. Her knees and elbows were bruised and bleeding by the time she came home.
However, Ryan never once looked back at her.
When Sofia was four, she begged Ryan for a very long time before he finally agreed to bring her to the amusement park. She held his hand and happily made her way there with him.
But when she accidentally called him "Daddy" again in the crowd, he immediately let go of her hand.
"You broke the rule again. You're not allowed to call me 'Daddy'."
The amusement park was a very large place for a four-year-old pup like Sofia, and she immediately got lost in the crowd.
By the time I managed to find her, she was curled up in the bushes behind a roller coaster ride, trembling and sobbing in fright.
From that day onward, she never dared to call Ryan "Daddy" again. It was also since then that the so-called "family" Ryan and I shared became a joke.
At that thought, my nose tingled with tears, and I hugged Sofia tightly in my arms.
"Sofia, Claire Barker is back. And she's the person whom Alpha Ryan has been waiting for all this time. We can't afford to stay here anymore."
Sofia's eyes dimmed. However, a split second later, she hurriedly showed me the rabbit toy and held it in front of me.
"But Mommy… The Alpha gave this to me today."
She stared at me expectantly with her round eyes and continued defending Ryan. "Mommy, if the Alpha doesn't like me, why would he still give me a present like this?"
I looked into her expectant eyes, unable to get another word out.
How was I supposed to tell her that Ryan had only hugged her and picked her up today because Claire, his first love, had just returned to the pack with her pup, Lily Barker?
How was I supposed to tell her that the rabbit toy actually originally belonged to Lily, but Ryan brought it back for Sofia because Lily just didn't want it anymore?
I couldn't bring myself to tell Sofia any of these things. I didn't want to ruin the loving image she had of her father. I had no choice but to hide the cruel truth from her again, just like how I always used to do in the past.
I lowered my head and kissed Sofia on the forehead. But when she wasn't looking, I quickly wiped away the tears forming at the corner of my eye.
This was my last shred of dignity as a mother, and the final illusion that I could preserve for Sofia. I swallowed the lump of emotion rising in my throat and asked her quietly, "Sofia, would you like to follow me and leave the pack?"
Sofia froze. After a very long time, she asked timidly, "Do we have to leave? I still haven't…"
She lowered her head and hugged the toy closer. "I still haven't called him 'Daddy' openly and proudly in public yet."
My tears finally rolled down my cheeks. I bit hard on my lips so as not to let my sobs out.
"Sofia, Alpha Ryan doesn't like us here. I'll take you away, okay?"
She remained silent for a long time. She slowly withdrew her arms and tightened her hold on the rabbit toy even more.
Finally, she looked up at me with teary eyes. "Then let's give the Alpha three more chances. If he still doesn't like us after those three times…"
She sniffled. "We'll leave him forever."
I closed my eyes. A long time later, I nodded and agreed to Sofia's request.
"Okay."
Sofia and I would give Ryan three last chances.
Chapter 2
News about Claire and her pup's return soon spread throughout the Moonshadow pack.
Apparently, the last time she left the pack, she'd joined the Silverfrost pack in the north and never came back over the years.
However, everyone knew that Ryan had never truly let go of her.
Back then, Ryan and Claire were the most celebrated couple in the pack. In fact, they were about to hold their mating ceremony.
But the day before it was supposed to happen, Claire suddenly fell in love at first sight with another Alpha from a different pack. So, she abandoned Ryan despite his protests and went after the other Alpha instead.
That was how their relationship ended.
Back then, I was just the pack's healer, and I often tended to Ryan's battle wounds. Over time, I gradually fell in love with him.
Once, when Ryan was heavily injured and out cold for days, I was the one who kept vigil by his bed for three days and sleepless nights. When he finally woke up, he grabbed my hand and thanked me for my companionship.
Then he began visiting me more often and even personally escorted me home at times. He also shielded me and defended me from the other pack members' harassment during pack gatherings.
I thought that he'd finally moved past the shadow of Claire's departure.
Later, we both got drunk at a victory celebration feast, and we ended up sleeping together. Because of that, I conceived Sofia, and Ryan formed a mate bond with me.
But it wasn't until after we were bonded that I realized he had married me not out of love, but out of duty.
Seven years passed, and I finally understood that the tenderness which made me believe I was loved never truly belonged to me at all.
That was the main reason why I finally decided to leave with Sofia last night.
I packed my things, got a potion to sever the mate bond from a witch, and handed in my application to leave the pack to the Elder in charge of administration.
"Erina Talbot? Are you sure that you want to leave the pack?" the Elder asked, staring at me in shock.
I nodded. "Yes. I've received an invitation from the Werewolf Research Institute in the north, and I plan to take Sofia along with me."
The Elder sighed. "Alpha Ryan has been rather busy lately. Perhaps you could both give it another try."
I forced a smile on my lips.
If it weren't for Sofia's sake, I would have already left a long time ago. Seven years was more than enough time for me to see Ryan's true heart.
It was also enough time for me to realize that some things would never come to fruition no matter how long I waited, simply because it was never meant to be.
I'd only just walked out of the administration department when I saw Claire.
She was dressed in a long white maxi dress while holding a little pup's hand. Ryan was right next to her, and he was wearing a gentle smile on his face, something that I hadn't seen in a very long time.
He couldn't even bear to remove his eyes from Claire for a second.
While a few other pack members passed by, I heard them say, "Goodness! It's been seven years, and I still think that the Alpha and Claire look much better as a couple."
"I know, right?"
I was the Luna who had been by Ryan's side for seven years. And yet, at this moment, I felt like nothing more than an outsider.
Since he didn't need me anymore, I didn't want to continue waiting for him either.
While brushing past him, Ryan finally caught sight of me and gave me a cold glare.
"Erina. Why were you looking for me here?"
There was a warning tone in his voice, reminding me to behave and remember my place. He probably thought that I had come here deliberately to "coincidentally" run into him, but I didn't bother explaining myself to him anymore.
"Nothing," I replied bluntly.
He replied with a faint grunt and immediately averted his eyes, continuing to look at Claire as though she were his whole world.
Ryan was my mate and my pup's father, but at this moment, he chose to give his undisguised love and attention to another she-wolf right in front of me.
It was pathetic. I chuckled self-deprecatingly at this thought.
I had initially wanted to tell him that I was planning to leave the pack, but now, it seemed like it wasn't even necessary anymore. After all, he never really paid attention to Sofia or me anyway.
I turned to leave, but I received a call from Sofia just at that moment.
"Mommy, you remember tonight's parents-teacher conference night, right? Ms. Redclaw said that we could all go home early today to prepare for tonight. Mr. Warrior is bringing me to you now!"
I was stunned for a second and instantly looked around, trying to find Sofia's little figure. But I'd only taken a few steps forward before I saw Ryan crouching and tenderly smoothing Lily's hair, tousled by the wind.
And Sofia was just about five feet away, with her backpack on her back.
She stood frozen at her spot. She watched with wide, shocked eyes as her own father acted so intimately with another pup she didn't know.
The loving tenderness in Ryan's eyes was something that neither Sofia nor I had ever seen before.
My heart sank. I was just about to take Sofia away when Ryan suddenly caught sight of her as well. He froze and awkwardly withdrew his hand.
But seconds later, he shielded Claire and Lily and walked past Sofia, slowly but decisively, as though he didn't know who she was.
My heart clenched at once. I hurriedly brought Sofia over to a nearby bench, but before I could attempt to explain things, Sofia looked up at me with teary eyes.
She asked me timidly, "Mommy, is that the she-wolf and pup that Alpha Ryan likes?"
In that moment, I lost all energy to speak and could only nod mechanically while biting my lower lip.
Sofia didn't press any further. She just stood quietly before me and took the rabbit toy from her back, caressing it gently. Still, she couldn't hold back her tears, and they dripped onto the toy's fur.
She tried her best to hold back her sobs as she fiercely wiped the tear stains dry on the rabbit's fur. I couldn't bear to watch anymore and pulled her into a tight embrace.
"You still have me, baby. And I love you more than anyone else in the world, okay?"
Ryan only had two more chances before Sofia and I left the pack for good.
Chapter 3
Sofia and I eventually made our way home. On the way back, she suddenly grabbed hold of my hand and asked quietly, "Mommy, can you ask Alpha Ryan to come to the parent-teacher meeting tonight at the preschool?"
I paused in my tracks. After all, little pups like her wouldn't understand the subtle hints and signs between adults—she simply wanted to hold onto the hope of receiving her father's love.
Throughout the seven years I'd been Ryan's mate, he had never once attended a single one of Sofia's preschool activities.
But when I saw the longing look in her eyes, I couldn't bring myself to say no. So I took out my phone and texted Ryan.
"Sofia has a parent-teacher meeting tonight at her preschool. Are you free to attend?"
As usual, Ryan never replied to my texts.
Sofia lowered her head in disappointment and tightened her hold on the rabbit toy. A long while later, she asked, "The Alpha doesn't want to come, does he?"
Then she smiled at me, acting sensible and pretending not to care.
"It's okay. I know the Alpha is very busy with work. I understand."
I felt a crushing weight on my chest when I heard Sofia speak so maturely to me. It hurt so much that I could barely even breathe.
I was just about to comfort her when my phone suddenly buzzed with a text message from Ryan.
"I'm free. I'll be there."
At that moment, a wave of surprise and delight washed over me. I showed Sofia the message and said, "Did you see that, Sofia? Daddy said that he'd be coming!"
Sofia was stunned momentarily. But a split second later, her eyes lit up with joy as well. She was so happy that she nearly jumped into the air.
This was the first time that Ryan had ever agreed to participate in her preschool activities.
As we continued making our way home, Sofia was even more excited than before. She wouldn't stop talking about her day, excitedly telling me about all the pack etiquette she'd learned and how often her teacher, Ms. Redclaw, had praised her during pup training.
She also told me that she'd won first place in the last pup competition, and most importantly, she had been successfully elected pup squad leader for this semester. She told me that Ms. Redclaw said the announcement would be officially made in front of the entire pack tonight at the meeting.
At this point, Sofia suddenly looked up at me and asked, "Mommy, do you think that Daddy will like me better after knowing how good I am now?"
I was taken aback at her question. A sharp pang then pierced into my chest at that moment.
I didn't answer her straightaway. I could only pray hard that Ryan wouldn't go back on his promise for tonight. At the very least, I hoped that Sofia would be able to experience her father's love just once before we finally left for good.
The sky began to darken, and we arrived at the preschool ahead of time.
The time for the meeting drew closer and closer, but Ryan still never appeared. I took out my phone, ready to text him, when I suddenly saw the Instagram story that Claire had uploaded just recently.
Her photo showed Ryan sitting next to Lily, his head bowed as he patiently held her hand and taught her how to assemble a house with wooden blocks.
The expression on his face held a tenderness that I'd never seen before.
The caption read, "He's playing with my pup for the first time—just like a good dad."
My fingers tightened. I turned to look at Sofia next to me, who was sitting quietly in her seat, also holding a set of wooden blocks in her hand.
They were the same Lego blocks, the same young pups, and they shared the same moment when a father's presence was needed—and yet Ryan was never there for Sofia.
Sofia seemed to notice my eyes on her and looked up at me. She asked cautiously, "Mommy, is Daddy busy at work again?"
I stared at her in a daze, not having the heart to tell her the truth—that her father wasn't busy working, but busy keeping another pup company.
I couldn't bring myself to say a word. Instead, I just gathered her into my arms like always and said, "It's okay. You still have me. I'll always be with you."
Sofia didn't ask any more questions and buried her face in the crook of my shoulder, staying quiet for a long time. Still, I could feel small droplets of tears falling onto my skin.
For the rest of the time, we never brought up Ryan's name again, as though he had never promised us anything tonight, and that he was never present in our family that only consisted of Sofia and me.
I lowered my head and looked at Sofia's reddened, teary eyes, finally feeling the last of my hope die out.
Ryan had let her down again. He only had one more chance left.
But just as Ms. Redclaw finished taking attendance, a sudden commotion broke out in the crowd. Both Sofia and I were completely stunned.
Ryan had actually come.
Sofia's eyes lit up at once. "Daddy?"
Chapter 4
Sofia waved excitedly at Ryan. "Daddy! Daddy, I'm over here!"
Ryan stood there, his pupils contracting slightly as his gaze fell upon her. "What are you doing here?"
I froze in my tracks at once.
He was the one who had personally agreed to attend the parent-teacher meeting tonight, yet his tone suggested we shouldn't have been here in the first place.
However, Sofia didn't pick up on the coldness in his voice and ran over to him excitedly.
"Daddy! You're really here! I'm so happy!"
Ryan frowned at once. "What did you just call me?"
Sofia's smile froze. Then, she immediately corrected herself with practiced ease and exclaimed, "Alpha Ryan! Ms. Redclaw said that she'd be announcing the pup squad leader today! And it's going to be me!"
She looked up at him with wide, expectant eyes. I knew that she was waiting to hear a word of praise from him. After all, this was the first time Ryan had ever attended one of her preschool activities.
However, Ryan only glanced at her nonchalantly and frowned, saying nothing.
Sofia's smile gradually faded.
Just then, another tiny figure rushed up and knocked Sofia to the ground. I immediately caught Sofia and pulled her close.
Lily threw herself at Ryan's legs and hugged him tightly, proudly calling out to him, "Uncle Ryan! You're here for Mommy and me!"
Ryan didn't even hesitate as he bent down and picked Lily up. Claire also walked over and gave Lily's cheek a playful tug.
"Lily! You have to apologize if you bump into someone!"
Only then did Ryan notice Sofia and me on the ground. He said awkwardly, "You're fine, right? Lily didn't mean it. Don't blame her. I'll apologize on her behalf."
Sofia and I were stunned. Sofia had never once received that kind of care or protection, and yet, he was giving it to someone else that easily.
I frowned when I saw the hurt look on Sofia's face.
"It's Sofia's parents-teacher meeting today. Why are you all here?" I asked.
Ryan avoided my gaze. "Oh. Claire just returned to the pack, and I arranged for her pup to attend this preschool."
Lily pouted and rolled her eyes, burying her face into Ryan's chest, acting like a spoiled brat.
"Why should I apologize? Who is that? How dare she try to take Uncle Ryan away from me? I hate her!"
Claire folded her arms before her chest and looked down on us condescendingly. "As you can see, Ryan belongs to us tonight."
Ryan avoided Sofia's expectant gaze and didn't deny a thing. His expression remained cool and nonchalant, as though he didn't care about me or Sofia at all.
In a daze, I recalled the day Claire returned. That was the first time I'd seen Ryan come home drunk, and it was also the first time he'd ever picked Sofia up in his arms.
When Sofia excitedly called him "Daddy", he didn't chide her for the first time ever and laughed instead.
At that point, I thought that he'd finally accepted Sofia as his pup, but it wasn't until now that I realized he'd simply mistaken her for someone else.
Sofia and I had just been fooling ourselves from the very start.
Sofia calmed down, the light in her eyes completely gone. "I'm sorry for disturbing you, Alpha Ryan."
She then looked up at him and forced an understanding smile on her face. "Mommy and I will go back to our seats now. Goodbye, Alpha Ryan."
She made sure to emphasize on the words "Alpha Ryan" at the end. Then she went back to her seat.
I was feeling extremely heartbroken for Sofia at this point, and my resentment toward Ryan also reached its peak.
Suddenly, Ryan grabbed me and asked, "Is Sofia okay?"
I saw him looking at Sofia in shock, as though he were trying to verify something. Was it because the pup who once refused to leave his side had now learned to keep her distance from him?
A wry, bitter smile appeared on my lips. It was getting ridiculous.
"She's just finally thought things through, Alpha Ryan."
He'd missed the very last chance that Sofia had given him.
I shrugged off his hand and went back to my seat next to Sofia. I could feel Ryan's eyes on my back until I sat back down, but none of it stirred my heart anymore.
The parent-teacher meeting began as scheduled.
Ms. Redclaw first warmly welcomed Lily. Then, she glanced apologetically at Sofia before announcing that Lily would be serving as the pup squad leader for the semester.
"We've appointed Lily as the squad leader to help her get to know everyone more quickly. Good luck, Lily!"
This was the role Sofia once wanted most, and a position she had worked incredibly hard to earn. But now, the moment Claire returned with her pup, Lily had managed to take everything so effortlessly.
I looked at Sofia with heartache in my eyes. However, she just looked up at me with a sweet, well-behaved smile and said, "It's okay, Mommy. We're leaving anyway. It doesn't make sense for me to be the squad leader anymore."
At the end of the meeting, I finished the paperwork to withdraw Sofia from the preschool and prepared to leave.
But just as we stepped outside, we ran into Ryan.
He stood by the roadside, looking as though he'd been waiting a long time. There was a stick of cotton candy in his hand.
"Why did you take so long? Let's go home together," Ryan said, holding out the cotton candy for Sofia.
In the past, this was something Sofia had looked forward to most—going home together. But now, it just sounded ironic to us.
Sofia politely rejected him and said, "Thank you, Alpha Ryan, but I've been having a toothache lately. I can't have sweets right now."
Ryan suddenly looked flustered. He'd never paid attention to Sofia, so he didn't know that she was currently at the age where she was losing her baby teeth.
He reached out to comfort her, but right at that moment, his phone rang. It was Claire.
"Ryan! Lily just had a nasty fall and is crying for you. Can you please come over to us right now?"
His expression changed. He then looked at Sofia.
Sofia just smiled faintly at him and said, "Go, Alpha Ryan. They need you more."
Ryan chose Claire and her pup once again. But Sofia and I weren't going to be upset about his decision anymore.
That night, Sofia and I took out the suitcases that we'd packed beforehand, threw away the rabbit toy, and headed straight for the airport.
Just before boarding, I drank the bond-severing potion. From now on, I wasn't going to have anything to do with Ryan anymore.
…
Meanwhile, the moment Ryan realized that the bond was being severed, his voice suddenly drifted into my mind.
"Erina Talbot! What the heck are you doing?"